Journal of Interactional Research in Communication Disorders, Advance Access

Diagnosogenic thinking in speech-language pathology and some viable alternatives

Judith Felson Duchan
Issued Date: 28 Aug 2019

Abstract


Diagnosis has long played a central role in the field of speech-language pathology. It governs how clinicians define what they do, who they work with, and how they carry out their practice. Diagnosis also impacts individual clients, often negatively. In this sense, our field can be characterized as diagnosogenetic. This article describes the historical role diagnosis has played in the field since the late nineteenth century, argues how diagnosogenic thinking can be probematic, and offers alternative ways of construing and executing our clinical practices.

Download Media

Advance access PDF (Price: £18.00 )

DOI: 10.1558/jircd.36997

References



Ambrose, N.  & Yairi, E. (2002).  The Tudor study: Data and ethics.  American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 11,190–203.

American Academy of Audiology (2010).  Practice Guidelines for the Diagnosis, Treatment, and Management of Children and Adults with Central Auditory Processing Disorder (CAPD).  Available from:  http://audiology-web.s3.amazonaws.com/migrated/CAPD%20Guidelines%208-2010.pdf_539952af956c79.73897613.pdf

American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. (1993). Definitions of communication disorders and variations [Relevant Paper]. Available from http://www.asha.org/policy/RP1993-00208/ 

American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. (1996). Inclusive practices for children and youths with communication disorders [Position Statement]. Available from http://www.asha.org/policy/PS1996-00223/

American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (2015). History of ASHA.  Available from http://www.asha.org/about/history/

Ayres, Alfred (1880). The Orthoepist: A Pronouncing Manual Containing about Three Thousand Five Hundred Words, Including a Considerable Number of the Names of Foreign Authors, Artists, etc., That Are Often Mispronounced. NY: Appleton.

Baker, E., Croot, K., McLeod, S., Paul, R. (2001). Psycholinguistic models of speech development and their application to clinical practice.  Journal of Speech, Hearing, and Language Research, 44, 685-702.  

Bamiou, D., Musiek, F., Luxon, L. (2001). Aetiology and clinical presentations of auditory processing disorders—a review.  Archives of Disease in Childhood, 85, 361-365.

Barnes, C. (1992). Emancipatory disability research: Product or Process?  http://disability-studies.leeds.ac.uk/files/library/Barnes-glasgow-lecture.pdf

Barton, L. (Ed.). (1996) Disability and Society: Emerging Issues and Insights. NY: Longman Publishing.

Beasley, D. & Manning, J. (1973) Experimenter bias and speech pathologists' evaluation of children's language skills. Journal of Communication Disorders 6, 93–101.

Bell, A. G. (1900)  Visible speech.  Werner’s Magazine, 25, March to August (pp. 213-221).

Bell, A. G. (1932). English Visible Speech in Twelve Lessons. 4th edition. Revised by Caroline A. Yale. Washington, D. C.: Volta Bureau.

Berko, J. (1958).  The child’s learning of English morphology.  Word, 150-177.

Biklen, J. & Duchan, J. (1994). "I am intelligent": The social construction of mental retardation, Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 19, 173-184.

Bonner, T.  (1963) American doctors and German universities: A chapter in international intellectual relations, 1870–1914. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.

Bloom L., & Lahey, B. (1978). Language Development and Language Disorders. New York: Wiley.

Brinkerhoff, C. (1880). The Brinkerhoff Method for singing.  The Voice, 2, 3, 64.

Brown, R. (1973). A First Language: The Early Stages.  Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Byng, S. & Duchan, J. (2005).  Social model philosophies and principles: Their applications to therapies for aphasia,  Aphasiology, 19, 906-922.

Chomsky, N. (1965). Aspects of the Theory of Syntax.  Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

Damico, J. & Armstrong, M. (1990-1991). Empowerment in the clinical context: The SLP as advocate.  The NYSSLHA Journal, 18, 34-44. 

Damico, J., Muller, N., & Ball, M. (2010). Social practical considerations in labeling. In J. Damico, N. Muller, & M. Ball (eds.). The Handbook of Language and Speech Disorders. (pp. 11-37). Malden, MA: Blackwell.

Duchan, J. (2001).  Impairment and social views of speech-language pathology: Clinical practices re-examined.  Advances in Speech Language Pathology, 3, 1, 37-45.
 
Duchan, J. (2004). Assessment frames.  Chapter 3 in J. Duchan, Frame Work in Language and Literacy (pp 42-71).  NY: Guilford Press.

Duchan, J. (2005) The phonetically-based speech therapy methods of Alexander Graham Bell. Journal of Speech Language Pathology and Audiology, 29, 70-72.

Duchan, J. (2011).  Diagnostic taxonomy of Stinchfield and Robbins. Available from:  http://www.acsu.buffalo.edu/~duchan/history_subpages/stinchfieldtaxonomy.html

Duchan, J. (2013) Professional issues: A view from history.  In R. Lubinski and M. Hudson (Eds.)  Professional issues in speech-language pathology.  (4th edition).  Cengage Learning.

Duchan, J. (2014).  Case studies and their frameworks: Positivist, interpretive, emancipatory.  In M. Ball, N. Muller, & R. Nelson (Eds.). Handbook of Qualitative Research in Communication Disorders. (pp. 3-16).  NY: Psychology Press. 

Duchan, J. (2015) The elocution movement.  Available from: http://www.acsu.buffalo.edu/~duchan/new_history/hist19c/elocution.html/ 

Duchan, J. and Katz, J. (1983). Language and auditory processing: Top down plus bottom up. In E. Lasky and J. Katz (eds.), Central Auditory Processing Disorders, 31-45. San Diego, Ca.: College Hill Press.

Duchan, J. & Kovarsky, D. (Eds.) (2005a). Diagnosis as cultural practice. Hawthorne, NY: Mouton De Gruyter Publishers.

Duchan, J. & Kovarsky, D. (2005b).  Introduction.  In J. Duchan & D. Kovarsky (Eds.) Diagnosis as Cultural Practice. (pp. 1-13).   NY: Mouton de Gruyter.

Dunglison, R. (1874)  A Dictionary of Medical Science (2nd ed.). Philadelphia, PA: Henry C. Lea.

Edwards, M. & Shriberg, L. (1983). Phonology: Applications in Communicative Disorders.  San Diego, CA: College Hill. 

Foster-Galasso, M. (2005).  Diagnosis as an aid and curse in dealing with others.  In J. Duchan & D. Kovarsky (eds.). Diagnosis as Cultural Practice. (pp. 17-31).  NY: Mouton de Gruyter.
    
Gill, V. & Maynard, D. (1995). On “labeling” in actual interaction: Delivering and receiving diagnoses of developmental disabilities.  Social Problems, 42, 1, 11-37. 

Green, S. (2003). “What do you mean ‘what’s wrong with her?’”: Stigma and the lives of families of children with disabilities.  Social Science & Medicine, 57, 1361–1374.

Ingram, D. (1982). The assessment of phonological disorders in children:  The state of the art. In M. Crary (Ed.). Phonological  intervention: Concepts and procedure. (pp. 1-12).  San Diego: College Hill Press.

Johnson, W.(1938). The role of evaluation in stuttering behavior. Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders, 3, 85–89.

Johnson, W. (1939). Language speech and hygiene.  General Semantics Monograph #1.

Jorgensen, C., McSheehan, M. & Sonnenmeier, R. (2010). The Beyond Access Model: Promoting Membership, Participation, and Learning for Students with Disabilities in the General Education Classroom.  Baltimore, MD: Brookes Publishing Co. 

Kagan. A. (2008). Supported conversation for adults with aphasia: Methods and resources for training conversation partners. Aphasiology, 12, 9, 816-830.

Kamhi, A. (2011). What speech-language pathologists need to know about auditory processing disorder. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 42, 265–272.

Katz, J. (1983). Phonemic Synthesis and other auditory skills. In E. Lasky and J. Katz (Eds.), Central Auditory Processing Disorders: Problems of Speech, Language and Learning, Baltimore MD: University Park Press.

Kirk, S. & McCarthy, J. (1961). Illinois Test of Psycholinguistic Abilities. Urbana, IL: The University of Illinois Press.

Kofler, L. (1889) Take Care of Your Voice: Vocal Hygiene, Practical Hints. NY: E. S. Werner.

Koppenhaver, D., Spadorcia, S., and Erickson, K. (1998). Inclusive early literacy instruction for children with disabilities. In S. B. Neuman, and K. Roskos (Eds.), Children Achieving: Instructional Practices in Early Literacy (p. 77-97). Newark, DE: International Reading Association.

Lahey, M. (1988). Language disorders and language development.  NY: Macmillan.

LPAA Project Group (2001) Life participation approaches to aphasia. In R. Chapey (Ed.) Language intervention strategies in aphasia and related neurogenic communication disorders. Fourth edition. Philadelphia, PA: Lippicott, Williams & Wilkins. (with R. Chapey, J. Duchan, R. Elman, A. Kagan, J. Lyon, N. Simmons Mackie)

Lund, N. & Duchan, J. (1983).  Assessing Children's Language in Naturalistic Contexts, Englewood Cliffs, NY: Prentice Hall. 

Manning, W. (2010)  Clinical Decision Making in Fluency Disorders.  San Diego, CA: Singular.

McCarthy, D. (1946). Language development in children. In L. Carmichael (Ed.), Manual of Child Psychology (pp. 476-581). NY: John Wiley & Sons.

Mercer, J. (1973).  Labeling the Mentally Retarded.  Berkeley: University of California Press.

Miller, J. (1981) Assessing Language Production in Children: Experimental Procedures. Austin, TX: Pro-ed.

Mowrer, O. H. (1954). A psychologist looks at language. The American Psychologist, 11, 9, 660-694.

Nation, J. & Aram, D. (1982). The diagnostic process.  In N. Lass, L. McReynolds, J. Northern, & D. Yoder (Eds.). Speech, Language and Hearing.  Volume II.  Pathologies of Speech and Language.  (pp. 443-476).  Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Saunders Company. 

Nittrouer, S. (2002). From ear to cortex: A perspective on what clinicians need to understand about speech perception and language processing. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 33, 237 – 252.


Oliver, M. (1988). If I had a hammer: The social model in action.  In J. Swain, S. French, C. Barnes, & C. Thomas (Eds.). Disabling Barriers—Enabling Environments.  Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.

Oliver, M. (1992) Changing the Social Relations of Research
Production, Disability, Handicap, & Society, 7, 2, 101-115.

Osgood, C. (1957). A Behavioristic Analysis of Perception and Language as Cognitive Phenomena. Contemporary Approaches to Cognition. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.

Paden, E. (1970). A history of the American Speech and Hearing Association. Washington, D. C.: The American Speech and Hearing Association.

Parr, S., Wimborne, N., Hewitt, A. and Pound, C. (2008) The Communication Access Toolkit. London: Connect Press. 

Porter, E. (1827) Analysis of the Principles of Rhetorical Delivery as Applied in Reading and Speaking. Andover: Flagg & Gould.

Potter, S. (1882). Speech and its Defects. Philadelphia: P. Blakiston Son and Co.

Rees, N. (1973). Auditory processing factors in language disorders: The view from Procrustes' bed. Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders. 38,  304–315

Robb, M. (1954). The elocutionary movement and its chief figures. In K. Wallace (ed). A History of Speech Education in America. (pp.181-184) NY: Appleton, Century Crofts.

Rosenthal, R. (1966). Experimenter Effects in Behavioral Research. NY: Appleton-Century-Crofts.

Rosenthal, R. & Jacobson, L. (1992) Pygmalion in the Classroom.  New York: Irvington (with Lenore Jacobson).

Schraeder, T., Quinn, M., Stockman, I. & Miller, J. (1999). Authentic assessment as an approach to preschool speech-language screening.
American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 8, 195-200.

Shriberg, L., & Kwiatkowski, J. (1980). Natural Process Analysis: A Procedure for Phonological Analysis of Continuous Speech Samples.
New York: Macmillan.

Stathopoulos, E. & Duchan, J. (2006). History and principles of exercise-based therapy: How they inform our current treatment. Seminars in Speech and Language, 27, 227-235.

Simmons-Mackie, N. (2000).  Social approaches to the management of aphasia. In L. Worrell & C. Fritalli (Eds.). Neurogenic Communication Disorders: A Functional Approach (pp. 162-187). NY: Thieme Medical Publishers. 

Skinner, B. F. (1957). Verbal Behavior.  Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. 

Stackhouse, J., & Wells, B. (1997). Children’s Speech and Literacy Difficulties: 1. A Psycholinguistic Framework.  London: Whurr. 

Stinchfield, S. and S. Robbins (1931). A Dictionary of Terms Dealing with Disorders of Speech. Boston, Expression Company.

Swain, J., French, S., Barnes, C. & Thomas, C.  (Eds.). Disabling Barriers—Enabling Environments.  Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.

Tallal, P. (1980). Auditory processing disorders in children. In P. Levenson, and C. Sloan (Eds.). Auditory Processing and Language (pp. 81-100). New York: Grune & Stratton.

Templin, M. (1957). Certain Language Skills in Children: Their Development and Interrelationships. Minneapolis: The University of Minnesota Press.

United States Access Board (2015) Mission.  http://www.access-board.gov/the-board

UPIAS (1976). Fundamental Principles of Disability. London: UPIAS.

Van Riper, C., (1981). An Early History of A.S.H.A."  ASHA Magazine, 23, 855-858.

Wepman, J., & Jones, L. (1961). The Language Modalities Test for Aphasia. Chicago: University of Chicago.


Wepman, J., Jones, L., Bock, D. & Van Pelt, D. (1960). Studies in aphasia: Background and theoretical formulations. Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders, 25, 323-332.

Werner, E. (1881). Stuttering therapy.  The Voice, 3, 1, 1-2.

Werner, E. (1887). Werner's Directory of Elocutionists, Readers, Lecturers, and Other Public Instructors and Entertainers. NY: Author.

West, R., Kennedy, L., & Carr, A. (1947).  The Rehabilitation of Speech.  2nd edition.  NY: Harper and Bros.

Wingate, M. (1962). Evaluation and stuttering: III. Identification
of stuttering and the use of a label. Journal of Speech and
Hearing Disorders, 27, 368–377.

Wingate, M. (1997). Stuttering: A Short History of a Curious Disorder. NY:  Praeger. 

Yairi, E., & Ambrose, N. (2001). The Tudor experiment and Wendell Johnson: Science and ethics reexamined. ASHA Leader, 6.13, 17.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.





Equinox Publishing Ltd - 415 The Workstation 15 Paternoster Row, Sheffield, S1 2BX United Kingdom
Telephone: +44 (0)114 221-0285 - Email: info@equinoxpub.com

Privacy Policy