Buddhist Studies Review, Vol 37, No 2 (2020)

Studying the Heart Sutra: Basic Sources and Methods (A Response to Ng and Ānando)

Jayarava Attwood
Issued Date: 24 Mar 2021


This article illustrates the importance of research methods in Buddhist Studies using the recent article on the Heart Sutra by Ng and Ānando (2019) as a case study. The authors make a novel conjecture about the Heart Sutra to explain a difference between the Xīnjīng (T 251) and the Dàmíngzhòujīng (T 250) but in doing so they neglect the relevant research methods and critical thinking. Their selection of literary resources is somewhat erratic and their evaluation of them appears to contain bias. The authors did not consult relevant Sanskrit texts (including the Sanskrit Heart Sutra). The logic applied to their source materials appears to be faulty at times and this causes them to arrive at an unconvincing conclusion. By going over the same ground, using more appropriate methods and materials, a far better explanation of the problem emerges.

Download Media

PDF (Price: £5.00 )

DOI: 10.1558/bsrv.41982


Attwood, J. 2015. ‘Heart Murmurs: Some Problems with Conze’s Prajñāpāramitāhṛdaya.’ Journal of the Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies 8: 28–48.

———. 2017a ‘‘Epithets of the Mantra’ in the Prajñāpāramitāhṛdaya.’ Journal of the Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies 12: 28-59.

———. 2017b ‘Form is (Not) Emptiness: The Enigma at the Heart of the Heart Sutra.’ Journal of the Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies13: 52–80.

———. 2018a. ‘A note on Niṣṭhānirvāṇaḥ in the Heart Sutra.’ Journal of the Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies 14: 10–17.

———. 2018b. ‘The Buddhas of the Three Times and the Chinese Origins of the Heart Sutra.’ Journal of the Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies 15: 9–27.

———. 2019. ‘Xuanzang’s Relationship to the Heart Sutra in light of the Fangshan Stele.’ Journal of Chinese Buddhist Studies 32 (): 1–30.

———. 2020a ‘Ungarbling Section VI of the Heart Sutra.’ Journal of the Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies 18: 11–41.

———. 2020b (forthcoming). ‘Edward Conze: A Call to Reassess the Man and his Contribution to Prajñāpāramitā Studies.’ Journal of the Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies 19.

Beal, Samuel. 1865. ‘The Paramita-hridaya Sutra or The Great Paramita Heart Sutra.’ Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain 1865: 25–28

Bucknell, Roderick S. 2010. ‘Taking Account of the Indic Source-text.’ In Translating Buddhist Chinese: Problems and Prospects, 45–52. Konrad Meisig (ed.). Harrassowitz Verlag.

Conze, Edward. 1948 ‘Text, Sources, and Bibliography of the Prajñāpāramitā-hṛdaya’. Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society 80 (1-2): 33–51.

———. 1958. Buddhist Wisdom Books: The Diamond Sutra and the Heart Sutra. George Allen & Unwin.

———. 1967. ‘The Prajñāpāramitā-Hṛdaya Sūtra’. In Thirty Years of Buddhist Studies: Selected Essays. Bruno Cassirer.

———. 1973. Buddhist Wisdom Books: The Diamond Sutra and the Heart Sutra. 2nd Ed. George Allen & Unwin.

Cook, Francis H. 1978. ‘Fa-tsang’s Brief Commentary on the Prajñāpāramitā-hṛdaya-sūtra’. In Mahayana Buddhist Meditation: Theory and Practice, Edited by Minora Kiyotapp, 167­–206. University of Hawai’i Press.

Copp, Paul. 2014. The Body Incantatory: Spells and the Ritual Imagination in Medieval Chinese Buddhism. Columbia University Press.

Eckel, Malcolm David. 1987. ‘Indian Commentaries on the Heart Sūtra: The Politics of Interpretation’. The Journal of the International Association of Buddhist Studies 10 (2): 69–79.

Fukui, F. 1987. Hannya Shingyō no Rekishiteki Kenkyū 般若心経の歴史的研究 [A historical study of the Heart Sūtra] (Tokyo: Shunjūsha).

———. 1994. ‘Hannaya shingyō no kenkyūshi - genkon no mondaiten.’ Bukkyōgaku 36: 79-99.

Harada Waso. 2010. Hannya shingyō seiritsu shiron: Daijō Bukkyō to Mikkyō no kōsaro. Tokyo: Daizō-shuppan.

Harrison, Paul. 2006. ‘Vajracchedikā Prajñāpāramitā: A New English Translation of the Sanskrit Text Based on Two Manuscripts from Greater Gandhāra’. In Buddhist Manuscripts in the Schøyen Collection (Vol. III), 133-159. Oslo, Hermes Publishing.

Huifeng. 2014. ‘Apocryphal Treatment for Conze’s Heart Problems: Non-attainment, Apprehension, and Mental Hanging in the Pañcaviṃśati’. Journal of the Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies 6: 72–105.

Hurvitz, Leon. 1975. “Two Polyglot Recensions Of The Heart Scripture.” Journal of Indian Philosophy 3 (1-2): 17–66.

———. 1977. ‘Hsüan-tsang 玄奘 (602-664) and the Heart Scripture’. In Prajnaparamita and Related Systems: Studies in Honor of Edward Conze, 103–113. University of California at Berkeley Press.

Hurvitz, L. N. and Link, A. E. 1974. ‘Three Prajñāpāramitā Prefaces of Tao-an.’ In Mélanges de Sinologie offerts à Monsieur Paul Demiéville, Vol. II, Bibliothèque de l’Institut des Hautes Études Chinoises, XX, 403–70. Presses Universitaires de France, .

Hyun Choo, B. 2006. ‘An English Translation of the Banya paramilda simgyeong chan: Wonch’uk’s Commentary on the Heart Sūtra (Prajñāpāramitā-hṛdaya-sūtra)’. International Journal of Buddhist Thought & Culture 6: 121–205.

Ishii Kōsei. 2015. ‘Issues Surrounding the Heart Sutra: Doubts Concerning Jan Nattier’s Theory of a Composition by Xuánzàng.’ Journal of Indian and Buddhist Studies (Indogaku Bukkyogaku Kenkyu) 64(1), 499­–492. [『般若心経』をめぐる諸問題 ―ジャン・ナティエ氏の玄奘創作説を疑う. Translated by Jeffrey Kotyk].

Ji Yun. 2017. ‘Is the Heart Sūtra an Apocryphal Text? – A Re-examination’. Singapore Journal of Buddhist Studies, 4 (): 9-113 (Trans. Chin Shih-Foong). Originally published in 2012. 纪赟 —《心经》疑伪问题再研究. Fuyan Buddhist Studies 7: 115–182.

Karashima, Seishi, et al. 2016. Mahāyāna Texts: Prajñāpāramitā Texts (1). Gilgit Manuscripts in the National Archives of India Facsimile Edition Volume II.1. The National Archives of India and The International Research Institute for Advanced Buddhology, Soka University, Tokyo.

Kimura, Takayasu. 1986-2009. Pañcaviṃśatisāhasrikā Prajñāpāramitā. 5 Vols. Tokyo: Sankibo Busshorin.

Matsumoto, Tokumyo. 1932. Die Prajñāpāramitā Literatur. Rheinischen Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universitat zu Bonn.

McBride, Richard D. 2005. ‘Dhāraṇī and Spells in Medieval Sinitic Buddhism’. Journal of the International Association of Buddhist Studies 28(1): 85–114.

McRae, John R. 1988. ‘Ch’an Commentaries on the Heart Sutra: Preliminary Inferences on the Permutation of Chinese Buddhism.’ Journal of the International Association of Buddhist Studies 11 (2): 85–115.

Müller, Max. 1884. ‘The Ancient Palm Leaves containing the Prajñāpāramitā-Hṛidaya Sūtra and Uṣniṣa-vijaya-Dhāraṇi’. In Buddhist Texts from Japan (Vol 1.iii). Oxford University Press.

Nattier, Jan. 1992. ‘The Heart Sūtra: a Chinese apocryphal text?’ Journal of the International Association of Buddhist Studies 15 (2): 153–223.

Ng, V. K. L. and Ānando, Phramaha Anon. 2019. ‘Sectarian Thoughts Alternations among Different Versions of the Prajñāpāramitāhṛdaya, the Heart Sūtra, until the Time of the Yogācāra School.’ The Journal of International Association of Buddhist Universities 12 (1): 165–186.

Schopen, G. 1997. Bones, Stones, and Buddhist Monks: Collected Papers on the Archaeology, Epigraphy, and Texts of Monastic Buddhism in India. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press.

Schopen, Gregory. 2004. ‘If you can’t Remember, How to Make it up, Some Monastic Rules for Redacting Canonical Texts.’ In Buddhist Monks and Business Matters: Still More Papers on Monastic Buddhism in India, 395­–407. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press.

Sharf, Robert H. 2001. Coming to Terms with Chinese Buddhism: A Reading of the Treasure Store Treatise. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.

Shih, Heng-Ching & Lusthaus, Dan. 2006. A Comprehensive Commentary on the Heart Sutra (Prajnaparamita-hyrdaya-sutra). Numata Center for Buddhist Translation & Research.

Silk, Jonathan A. (1994) The Heart Sūtra in Tibetan: a Critical Edition of the Two Recensions Contained in the Kanjur. Arbeitskreis für Tibetische und Buddhistische Studien, Universität Wien.

Storch, T. 2014. The History of Chinese Buddhist Bibliography. Amherst, NY: Cambria Press.

Suzuki, D. T. 1934. Essays in Zen Buddhism: third series. Red Wheel/Weiser, 1971.

Tanahashi, Kazuaki. 2014. The Heart Sutra: A Comprehensive Guide to the Classic of Mahayana Buddhism. Shambala.

Tokuno, Kyoko. 1990. ‘The Evaluation of Indigenous Scriptures in Chinese Buddhist Bibliographical Catalogues’. In Chinese Buddhist Apocrypha, edited by Robert E Buswell, 31-74. University of Hawaii Press.

Victoria, Brian. 2013. ‘D.T. Suzuki, Zen and the Nazis’. The Asia-Pacific Journal 11, Issue 43(4): 1–22.

Watanabe, Shōgo. 1991. “An introduction to the Theory on the Formation of the Prajñā-hridaya-sūtra,” Journal of Buddhist Studies 31: 41­–86. 「般若心経成立論序説」 『仏教学』

Wayman, Alex. 1977. ‘Secret of the Heart Sutra’. In Prajñāpāramitā and Related Systems: Studies in Honor of Edward Conze. Edited by Lewis R. Lancaster, Luis O. Gómez, 135–152. Group in Buddhist Studies, UC Berkeley.

Whitney, W. D. 1885. The Roots, Verb-forms and Primary Derivatives of the Sanskrit Language. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 2006.

Yusa, Michiko. 2019. ‘D. T. Suzuki and the Logic of Sokuhi, or the Logic of Prajñāpāramitā’. In The Dao Companion to Japanese Buddhist Philosophy, 859-616. New York: Springer.

Zürcher, Eric. 1959. The Buddhist Conquest of China: The Spread and Adaptation of Buddhism in Early Medieval China. Leiden: E. J. Brill.


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Equinox Publishing Ltd - 415 The Workstation 15 Paternoster Row, Sheffield, S1 2BX United Kingdom
Telephone: +44 (0)114 221-0285 - Email: info@equinoxpub.com

Privacy Policy